I had to rewrite this one for school. It's written as a report, and I'm required to post it on the internet.
Crookedstar’s Promise by Erin Hunter
After over a year of waiting for Crookedstar’s Promise, I finally got it and blew through it over a course of three days. This book was one of the best books that I’ve read in ages, and exceeded all of my expectations. It has rejection, fantasy, battle, adventure, betrayal, and humor. It seems to have pretty much every category.
When Crookedstar was a kitten, then called Stormkit, he was playing with his brother, Oakheart, who was then called Oakkit, when he slipped and fell onto a stone and broke his jaw. He was permanently disfigured, so his mother, Rainflower, renamed him Crookedkit.
When he gets his apprentice name, Crookedpaw, he is upset because his mentor is “Treating him like a kitten.” When a Starclan warrior, or warrior ancestor from cat-heaven, named Mapleshade offers to train him, and he accepts. But it comes with conditions. Crookedpaw must promise her that he will put his clan before anything else. He promises, not thinking much of it.
After a long apprenticeship, Crookedpaw receives his warrior name, Crookedjaw. He becomes a powerful warrior, and after his father, Shellheart, steps down from position as clan deputy, Crookedjaw is chosen. Eventually after Hailstar, Riverclan’s leader dies; Crookedjaw is promoted to leader and takes on the name of Crookedstar. When Crookedstar becomes leader, he must face many new challenges as well as coping with the past.
I think that Crookedstar’s life may or may not be too perfect. This book could be so depressing, it dealt with the death of loved ones, love, battle, and betrayal, but Crookedstar always did figure out a way to pull through. One of the only things that he didn’t accomplish was making his mother, Rainflower, proud of him, which was a major thorn in the plot. Other side characters like Oakheart (formerly Oakpaw), Willowbreeze (his mate), Hailstar (clan leader), Rainflower, and Shellheart were just a few of the characters who had decent sized rolls within this 491 paged book. There were so many characters that this book would have been extremely overwhelming for anyone who hadn’t read any of the various Warrior Cats series (Warriors, The New Prophecy, The Power of Three, and Omen of the Stars, and various super editions and fan guides). Luckily, there was an “Alliances” page in the front of the book listing cats and their roles. But the list quickly becomes out of date as the story progresses, and you have to keep up with it yourself.
So personally, I love this book because it was a nice change from the stories in the lives of various Thunderclan cats, and it helped show how life was different between all of the clans. Young children might not like this book, it may be classified as 10 and up, because the battles could be violent, but it wasn’t too bad. So all in all, I highly recommend this and give it 5 stars!